A new movement to treat troubled children as ‘sad, not bad’
6th February 2017 · 0 Comments
By Katy Reckdahl
Contributing Writer
Editor’s note: This article is part two of a WWNO story series focusing on trauma amongst school-aged children called, “Kids, Trauma and New Orleans Schools.”
(Special from The Hechinger Report) — On dress-down days, Sherlae’s outfits almost always include sequins and sparkles. Whenever she passes a window, she lights up, in a way that matches her sunny personality and big, dimpled smile.
But for years, because of strife at home, she had to force herself to look cheerful each morning as she walked into her school, Lawrence D. Crocker College Prep in uptown New Orleans. “I always try to put on a happy, smiling — not sad — face,” said Sherlae, 13, whose middle name is used here to protect her privacy.
Today, that smile more often reflects an authentic happiness. But when her mood clouds, she knows how to address it. After a recent sleepless night when her mom visited, talking loud, a bottle of whiskey in hand, Sherlae walked off the yellow bus and into Crocker’s social-work office.
Her favorite confidante is social worker Rochelle Gauthier. “She’ll talk to me. Or just give me tissues and hugs,” Sherlae said.
All day long, a steady stream of Crocker students, feeling overwhelmed and needing to talk, ask teachers for passes to Gauthier’s office. Some want reassurance that they’ll be okay after water or electricity is shut off at home; others are burdened with worries about a loved one who is sick, has been arrested, or even killed. Some, like Sherlae, are coping with a family mental-health crisis.
In New Orleans, Crocker is at the vanguard of a collaborative of five schools launched in 2015 by the city’s health department. At each school, educators, experts in psychiatry and development, and mental-health providers work together to improve academic achievement by establishing a place where students can feel a sense of belonging and safety.
The concept behind these so-called “trauma-informed schools” is supported by research showing that traumatized students — those who have been exposed to repeated violence, abuse and deprivation — maintain such high levels of vigilance and anxiety that they cannot flourish at school until they can calm themselves.
In the past, this group of misunderstood students — even those within Crocker’s own charter network, New Orleans College Prep — often faced harsh punishment. Five years ago, Crocker’s sister schools, Cohen College Prep and Sylvanie Williams College Prep, suspended more than half their students, 51 percent, during the school year. (Parallel data wasn’t available for Crocker, which was run by a different charter operator at the time.)
The rigid “no excuses” disciplinary approach kept students out of class. It simply didn’t work for about a third of suspended students, said Amanda Aiken, a College Prep administrator who was Crocker’s principal when the school began to implement a trauma-informed model in 2015. Armed with new knowledge, Aiken now keeps trauma foremost in her mind, even when interviewing teachers. “I always ask, ‘What is your struggle?’ Because if you can’t understand struggle, you can’t work here,” she said.
All too often, New Orleans students have experienced serious trauma, such as shootings and other violence, said Denese Shervington, a board-certified psychiatrist who heads the local Institute of Women and Ethnic Studies and works closely with Crocker. “Over half of the kids we surveyed in middle school had someone close to them who had been murdered,” Shervington said. Almost 20 percent of the children surveyed said they had personally witnessed a murder in their community; 54 percent experienced the murder of a close family member or friend; nearly 40 percent had been exposed to domestic violence; and 29 percent worried about not being loved. The Institute found that rates of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder in New Orleans youth were nearly three times the national average.
For Tulane University psychology chair Stacy Overstreet, a leader of the five-school collaborative, work with Crocker and other trauma-sensitive schools flows from her work in New Orleans’ public-housing projects, where she found shockingly high rates of children suffering the psychological effects of being exposed to violence. And when trauma and chaos are ongoing and chronic, the effects are even worse, she concluded.
Crocker’s work is part of a national trend, driven by a massive, landmark public-health study called Adverse Childhood Experiences, or ACEs, which showed that trauma, even among the study’s relatively middle-class participants, is far more common than previously believed. The study found that almost two-thirds of adults experienced at least one traumatic event during childhood, through exposure to violence or personal abuse and neglect, findings since replicated by a number of other large studies.
Educators’ shift in attitude toward traumatized students has been hastened by parallel research showing that repeated or prolonged trauma can actually change a child’s brain. Neuroscientists have found that those altered brains — adapted for survival in the worst conditions — may cause traumatized children to react differently, struggling to connect with peers and adults and wrestling with basic language development and learning.
In other words, unaddressed trauma is an educational problem. Students consumed by sadness or anger are often unable to focus on learning.
While “trauma-informed” schooling might sound idealistic and even touchy-feely, it’s actually rooted in a series of practical steps, based on a significant body of research.
At Crocker, teachers and staff were trained to recognize trauma and learn how it affects children’s development. They learned to structure each day so that students always know what’s coming next, because unexpected changes can rattle traumatized children. At a school-wide level, administrators shelved mandatory, zero-tolerance suspension-expulsion requirements, replacing them with more flexible procedures that try to get at the root of misbehavior.
Students also became part of the change, learning how to support each other through one-on-one sessions with Gauthier and through classroom curricula devoted to teaching them how to be good friends, by asking questions and listening when others seem sad or angry.
Traumatized children often can’t express what’s going on inside them, so they throw tantrums and disrupt classrooms. “Those students are trying to tell you something,” Shervington said. Others shut down. “The kid with her head down on her desk may be more at risk than the child who is acting out,” Shervington said.
Teachers at Crocker have found that, once trained in trauma’s effects, they can detect them from even subtle clues. For example, Murray sensed a change in an A student. Although usually diligent, he’d failed to turn in a project. When she asked him about it, he didn’t have an explanation. Other small things also seemed out of character, she said.
Murray tapped into the computerized system teachers use to rate every student during each class period, a requirement of the trauma-informed framework. Teachers award each child a total of five possible points, for five different factors: how a student enters the classroom and exits to the next class, along with behavior, participation and completion of classwork. Murray found that the A student had dropped from five points to three or four in nearly all of his classes. She referred him to Gauthier and now knows that the student had gone through some upheaval at home and was adjusting to living with his grandma, not his mother.
Last year, Gauthier began to actively seek out the school’s quieter — and possibly “shut down” —children, after several, including Sherlae, became suicidal.
Sherlae has lived with her grandmother since she was about three, when her mother, who is bipolar and schizophrenic, stopped taking her medicine and turned to alcohol. There have been some periods of sobriety and calm, at these times Sherlae and her mom go on lengthy bike rides or walk to the library to research Sherlae’s book reports. “It can be so joyful,” Sherlae said.
But it can change quickly. A few years ago, during a lengthy bender, Sherlae’s mother became physically abusive and cruel.
“She put her hands on me. She told me she didn’t want me in the world,” Sherlae said. Her grandmother remembers Sherlae’s reaction. “It crushed her,” she said.
Ashamed, Sherlae told no one. For weeks, she did nothing at school but put her head on her desk. She couldn’t pay attention. Her grades plunged to Fs. She wanted to hurt herself. When she told a teacher she felt suicidal, the teacher sent an S.O.S. through the school’s message system, reaching Gauthier, who pulled Sherlae out of class.
At first, Sherlae wondered if she was in trouble. Then Gauthier asked her, “What makes you sad?” Sherlae initially resisted, then spilled everything. “I let all my feelings and emotions out with her,” Sherlae said. “And that was when my grades started going up.”
Sherlae is now on the honor roll.
Sherlae used to keep her emotions to herself. But now, thanks to guidance from Gauthier, she writes poems in her journal or talks with her two closest friends when she feels upset. Or she seeks out music. “It speaks to me,” she said.
“Young people try to normalize violence, but inside they’re very frightened and worried,” Shervington said.
New Orleans child-poverty rates stand at nearly 44 percent — more than double the national average. “These young people are in survival mode,” said Shervington, who talks every day with children who face unrelenting worries about basic needs like food, shelter, clothing, or love. “They tend to be hyper-vigilant, a little bit on edge. And they can feel a mild paranoia: ‘Am I okay? Will I make it today?’”
To help explain the link between trauma and children’s misbehavior, the Institute began to describe children’s struggle through a public-education campaign that uses the hashtag “sad, not bad.”
When students are viewed as “sad, not bad,” they can let down their guard and relax, said longtime New Orleans youth advocate Kathleen Whalen, another leader in the five-school collaborative. “School can be a good place to give your hippocampus a chance to catch up,” she said, referring to an area of the brain that is particularly sensitive to traumatic stress and essential to learning and memory.
Research to date shows that maybe 80 percent of children who have trauma histories will thrive in a trauma-informed environment without further interventions, Whalen said. When students need individual support, the collaborative’s mental-health providers step in..
At least 20 states have implemented trauma-informed schools at some level. Since 2014, the National Conference of State Legislatures has supported a “strong state-federal partnership” for trauma-informed education and awareness; last year, the concept was referenced for the first time in the federal Every Student Succeeds Act. Massachusetts, Washington and Oregon, among other states, have established wide-ranging resolutions or initiatives, as have some city school districts, such as San Francisco. In other states, like Louisiana, mere clusters of schools are trying it.
The approach is an about-face from the punitive, “no-excuses” mindset that became common in many schools in the mid-1990s and led to a national spike in suspensions and expulsions.
“We’re trying to get schools to respond differently to children,” said Overstreet, the Tulane psychology chair. “Instead of asking, ‘What’s wrong with that kid?’ which usually leads to punishment, ask ‘What happened to that kid?’”
At Crocker, punishment is no longer automatic. A teacher must discuss students’ behavior with a dean before putting them out of class or giving them a lunch detention.
Murray feels her training helps her interact more effectively with students.
Crocker teachers have also learned to acknowledge their own triggers — how, for instance, a certain hairstyle or fashion can cause them to see a child as defiant. They learn to call in help when they recognize they’re angry. Whenever Murray feels herself becoming exasperated, she can send an instant message that brings a fellow teacher to her classroom within minutes to take the situation off her hands.
Overstreet and her team recently began gathering baseline data as part of a controlled $2.6 million National Institute of Justice study focused on schools in the New Orleans collaborative. Using a number of criteria, including reduced school violence, fewer expulsions and suspensions, lower rates of teacher burnout, and several measures of academic success, the study will determine what factors make trauma-informed approaches effective.
This story was produced by The Hechinger Report, a nonprofit, independent news organization focused on inequality and innovation in education. Read more about education in New Orleans.
This article originally published in the February 6, 2017 print edition of The Louisiana Weekly newspaper.
